Can I Have That Shrug Pattern?

Mar 30, 2007

Many of you wrote and asked for a photo of the beautiful crocheted shrug that Kerry lent me to cover the Wardrobe Malfunction, so here is my friend Danielle modelling it for us:
Danielle in the nifty shrug

It’s got a pineapple motif at the sides, back, and cuffs; the rest is a V-stitch mesh. It’s a lightweight cotton/poly blend, done at a pretty fine gauge. Very nice.

Do I have the pattern for it? Nope. Can I tell you where to buy it? Nope. I will tell you that I did a pretty extensive internet search to try to find one just like it for myself and I utterly failed.

I thought of trying to reverse-engineer the shrug so I could make one like it, but the stitches are small, and it’s black, and although I have my trusty Ott-Lite and a strong magnifying glass, I lack the time and the patience right now to do the pattern justice.

Besides, sometimes I just want to admire someone else’s work, without trying to figure out how to do it myself. I know I could crochet a shrug just like this one, and I know I could come up with the pattern—but just because I can doesn’t mean I should. Some unnamed woman, likely a very poor woman, made this lovely garment, and she deserves the credit for its design and construction. For now, I’d just like to admire her skill and artistry, and let her work speak for itself.

Imitation may be a form of flattery, but sometimes I wonder where the line is between imitation-as-flattery and a disrespectful stealing of someone else’s creative ideas.

Now, there’s a hot topic. Tell me what you think, and let’s see if we can draw on our collective wisdom and find a way to inspire each other’s creativity while still respecting creative ownership.


Filed under:
Related Posts
+ Add a comment

Comments

on Dec 30, 2008 4:26 AM
It's not a giant leap for mankind but a big step for me - I've learned (amend that - I'm learning) to use a graph for the knitting pattern instead of reading the full instructions. I've always followed a graph for colour work, like a fairisle pattern, but all those different symbols had always beaten me. I wouldn't say I'm comfortable yet but I'm doing it! Thanks so much for Knitting Daily - I couldn't live without it. Margaret
BonniR wrote
on Aug 8, 2007 1:16 PM
When you have tired of the fab shrug, or when the laboriously created stitches (in poor lighting I am sure) begin to fail, you are welcome to send it to me and I will gladly re-create the pattern. I would even be willing to make a few minor adjustments, like knitted cuffs for more comfort and ?stay-puttedness,? so that it is not an exact copy of the original garment and maybe could be made available to the heartbroken knitters & crocheters out there who are sadly without the pattern to go with the inspiration.
In the meanwhile, I will begin to work on a ?Pineapple Shrug? of my own design.
Stay tuned?
Bee